Joe's Pizza Plaza Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Joe's Pizza Plaza, your go-to spot for delicious, hearty fare nestled in the heart of York, Pennsylvania. This family-owned gem boasts a menu that celebrates classic flavors with a twist. From the juicy Big Boy sandwich featuring two burger patties to the crispy Fried Chicken and Crab sandwiches, each item is crafted with fresh ingredients for an unbeatable taste.
Don't miss their stellar steak subs, especially the Super Cheese Steak, loaded with savory meat and flavorful toppings. For a lighter option, the chicken tenders and shrimp baskets perfectly complement your meal. Customers rave about the pizza and stromboli, highlighting their generous portions and well-balanced flavors.
Joe's Pizza Plaza also prides itself on welcoming service and a great atmosphere, making it a perfect place to satisfy cravings for classic American comfort food. Try their famous cheeseburger sub and you might just find a new favorite!
Sandwiches
Big Boy
Two burger patties, cheese, mayo, lettuce and tomato on a round roll.
Cheeseburger
Plain.
Chicken Parm
Choice of fried or grilled chicken, sauce and mozzarella cheese.
Crab
Fried crab patty with lettuce and tomato your choice of tartar, mayo, ketchup, or mustard cheese is extra .25.
Fish
Fried fish with lettuce and tomato choice of tartar, mayo, ketchup, or mustard cheese is extra .25.
Fried Chicken
Fried chicken with mayo, lettuce, and tomato on a round roll.
Grilled Chicken
Grilled chicken with mayo, lettuce, and tomato on a round roll.
Hamburger
Plain.
Pizzaburger
Beef patty, sauce and mozzarella cheese on a round roll.
Steak Sub
Steak'em not chopped with cheese, lettuce, tomato, and raw onion.
Cheese Steak
Includes steak'em, cheese, and fried onions and additional toppings are .30.
Chopped Steak
Includes meat and fried onions already chopped together with Italian herbs we add sauce to this sub.
Italian Steak
Steak'em on a round roll with cheese, fried onions, pickles and tomato.
Super Cheese Steak
Includes meat, cheese, fried green peppers, mushrooms, sauce, mozzarella cheese and pepperoni.
Steak Subs
Baskets
Chicken Tenders
Breaded chicken tenders fried.
Wings
Your choice of hot or mild.
Shrimp
Breaded shrimp fried.
Crab Sandwich With Fries
Experience the taste of the sea with our succulent crab housed between perfectly toasted bread. Complement it with our hand-cut fries, fried golden-brown, and seasoned to perfection. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Fish Sandwich With Fries
Sandwich made with a piece of cut fish that is either fried baked or grilled.
Platters
Italian Ice
Homemade Italian Ice (Double)
Enjoy a double serving of homemade Italian ice available in a variety of flavors: from fruity coconut, grape, and mango to indulgent chocolate, vanilla, and root beer. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Homemade Italian Ice (Pint)
Savor the frozen delights of a pint-sized homemade Italian ice. This dessert brims with an array of flavor choices. From tropical pineapple and ripe banana to rich chocolate or tangy sour apple, every option offers a refreshingly sweet and frosty experience. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Homemade Italian Ice (Quart)
Quart of homemade Italian ice, available in various flavors including fruity and creamy options. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Homemade Italian Ice (Single)
Indulge in a single serving of our homemade Italian ice available in a range of flavors such as Strawberry, Grape, Cotton Candy, Rainbow, Watermelon, Chocolate, Jolly Rancher mix, Banana, Cherry, Coconut, Sour Apple, Pina Colada, Mango, Orange, Root Beer, Blue Raspberry, Lemon, and Vanilla. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Parfait
Two scoops of Italian Ice with vanilla ice cream in the middle.
Juices
Enjoy our refreshing juice beverages available in large, medium, or small sizes. Choose from an array of flavors like zingy Fruit Punch or tangy Crystal Light Lemonade. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Soda
Choice of flavors.
Milkshakes
Indulge in our creamy milkshakes, available in a range of flavors including cherry, chocolate, pumpkin spice, vanilla, strawberry, and cinnamon. Choose between small or large sizes. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Beverages
Subs and Boats
Meatball Sub
Authentic Italian meatballs in sauce topped with mozzarella cheese then baked in the oven
Sausage Sub
Sweet Italian Sausage (a little spicy) with grilled onions and peppers and Pizza sauce
Cheeseburger Sub
Cheese, Onion, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Oregano
Chopped Chicken
Includes chopped grilled chicken fried onions and cheese.
Cold Cut Sub
Onion, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Oil, Oregano
Eggplant Sub
A long sandwich on a roll.
Fishboat
Enjoy a delicious Fishboat, embellished with quality fish, cooked to perfection. Shape your experience by choosing from our size options: large or small. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Ham Club
A delightful combination of savory ham layered with crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes, placed between lightly toasted bread. Prepared in two sizes to suit your appetite. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Italian
Onion, lettuce and tomatoes with oil and oregano
Super Chicken
Includes grilled chicken chopped, fried onion, green peppers, mushrooms, sauce, mozzarella cheese, and pepperoni.
Turkey Club
Tender turkey paired with crispy bacon, and served with fresh lettuce, tomato, and cucumber, all enclosed within perfectly toasted bread. Choose between large or small sizes. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
2 Slices Of Cheese Pizza & A Medium Drink
Two slices of classic cheese pizza, paired with a choice of a medium drink - options include Mr. Pibb, Root Beer, Raspberry Tea, Sprite, Diet Coke, or Coca-Cola. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Large 1 Topping Pizza & 2 Ltr Of Soda
A generous large pizza adorned with your choice of topping, partnered with a chilled 2 liter soda of your preference. Choose from an array of flavorful toppings and refreshing beverages. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Round Steak Sandwich, Small Fry & Small Drink
Tender round steak in a sandwich, paired with crispy small fries and a choice of refreshing drink. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Large 1 Topping Pizza, 5 Wings (Hot Or Mild) & 2 Ltr Of Soda
Large pizza with a choice of topping, 5 chicken wings in either hot or mild, and a 2-liter soda. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Small Sub, Bag Of Chips & Medium Drink
A small sub sandwich served with a side of crunchy chips and your choice of a medium-sized beverage. Options include Root Beer, Coca-Cola, Raspberry Tea, Mr. Pibb, Diet Coke, or Sprite. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Combos
Stromboli
Cheese Steak (Large)
Meat, cheese, fried onions and sauce.
Cheese Steak (Small)
Meat, cheese, fried onions and sauce.
Chicken (Large)
Chicken (Mini)
Chicken (Small)
Meatball (Large)
Meatball (Mini)
Original (Small)
Comes with sauce inside the boli.
Pretzel Boli (Large)
Large pretzel boli with choice of chicken, cheesesteak, ham and cheese, or original. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Pretzel Boli (Small)
A smaller Pretzel Boli, packed with your choice of Cheesesteak, the Original, Ham and Cheese, or Chicken. Description generated by DoorDash using AI
Super Cheese (Large)
Super Cheese (Mini)
Super Cheese (Small)
Veggie (Large)
Veggie (Mini)
Veggie (Small)
Cheese Steak (Mini)
Meat, cheese, fried onions and sauce.
Meatball (Small)
Original (Large)
Comes with sauce inside the boli.
Original (Mini)
Comes with sauce inside the boli.
White Pizza
A blend of Italian herbs and cheeses with tomatoes.
Fresh Dough Pizza (Large)
Fresh Dough Pizza (Mini)
Fresh Dough Pizza (Slice)
Fresh Dough Pizza (Small)
Works Pizza
Savory pie with a dough base topped with sauce and cheese.
Pizza
Salads
Chef Salads
Cold Cut -Ham, Bologna, Cooked Salmi, Mozzarella Cheese On top of tossed salad Italian Chef Salad - Capicollo Ham, Genoa Salami, Pepperoni and Mozzarella Cheese Turkey Chef - Turkey, Ham and Mozzarella Cheese Tuna Chef - Fresh Tuna Salad and Mozilla Cheese Grilled Chicken Chef Fried Chicken Chef
Tossed
Iceberg Lettuce, Tomatoes, Shredded Red Cabbage and Carrots
Tossed With Cheese
Our Tossed Salad topped with Mozzarella Cheese
2 Large Cheese Pizza
Pizza Special
Sides
Breaded Cauliflower
Coated in breadcrumbs and then baked or fried.
Breaded Mushrooms
Coated in breadcrumbs and then baked or fried.
Cheese Sticks
Commonly known as mozzarella.
French Fries
Our delicious french fries are deep fried 'till golden brown with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. seasoned to perfection
Fried Eggplant Bites
Cooked in oil.
Garlic Bread
Bread topped with garlic & olive oil or butter herb seasoning baked to perfection. melts in your mouth and arouses the taste buds.
Onion Rings
Crispy onion slices deep-fried until golden-brown.
Sweet Potato Tots
Fried grated potatoes.